In Dirig v. State, No. 26S-CR-399 (Ind. Nov. 16, 2026), the Indiana Supreme Court vacated a Level 1 felony neglect of a dependent conviction because two unobjected-to final instructions told the jury to measure the defendant against a “reasonable caregiver” rather than asking whether he knowingly endangered the child. Writing for a 3-1 majority, Justice Molter held that the error was fundamental, even though other instructions correctly stated the “knowing” standard. Justice Slaughter dissented, and Justice Goff did not participate.
This decision came down four days after the Court of Appeals’ decision in Miles v. State, which reached the opposite result on a similar question: whether a correct instruction can cure an incorrect one when the defense did not object. More on that comparison below.
The Facts
The defendant moved in with his girlfriend and her 8-year-old son in June 2022. The child had serious behavioral and emotional problems, including ODD and ADHD diagnoses, and had previously threatened suicide and wrapped a cord around his neck. The defendant knew this. He also knew about a later incident in which the child wrapped a towel around his throat at a babysitter’s. The mother agreed, reluctantly, to the defendant’s suggestion that the child’s bedroom door be modified to lock from the outside for time-outs, but she told him the child should be locked in only for short periods.
In September 2022, the child was hospitalized at Parkview Behavioral Health. The defendant signed a family safety plan that included removing choking hazards from the home. After discharge, the child started new medication and improved markedly, with essentially no school incidents in October and November.
On November 22, 2022, the defendant picked the child up from the Boys & Girls Club after an aggressive outburst. Staff reported that the defendant handled it well. When the outburst continued at home, the defendant locked the child in his room and played video games for about an hour. The mother came home and found the child unresponsive with a zip tie tightened around his neck. The defendant told police he used zip ties for work and had given some to the child for crafts and play.
The jury convicted the defendant of Level 1 felony neglect of a dependent resulting in death, and the trial court imposed 40 years.
The Instructions
Two instructions got the mens rea for the offense right. But two of the instructions got it wrong. The two erroneous instructions indicated that the jury was to evaluate the defendant’s conduct using a “reasonable caregiver” standard.
Defense counsel did not object. On appeal, the Court of Appeals agreed the two instructions were wrong but found no prejudice/harm from the instructions. It reasoned that, when read together with the correct instructions, the erroneous instructions actually increased the State’s burden of proof by requiring both a subjective awareness plus an objective awareness standard. The supreme Court granted transfer.
The Majority: The Instructions Diminished the State’s Burden
The final instruction that defined the offense of neglect used a definition from a Court of Appeals case that had been overruled. The other erroneous final instruction repeated the mistake by doubling down on the objective “reasonable caregiver” standard. The majority held that the error helped the State, and not the defense, because, in the most generous reading, the correct and erroneous instructions conflicted with one another. The conflict may have misled the jury.
The Majority: The Error was Fundamental
The majority also held that because nothing cured the error, the State’s closing argument mixed the correct and incorrect standards, and the State’s witnesses presented testimony on the best practices of a caregiver (i.e., what a reasonable caregiver would do), the error was fundamental. The Court also noted that the nature of the case made the error particularly harmful.
Justice Slaughter’s Dissent
Justice Slaughter agreed that the instructions were incorrect but argued that the error was not fundamental.
Dirig and Miles: Same Question, Opposite Answers
Recently I discussed the Court of Appeals’ published opinion in Miles. Miles and Dirig asked the same basic question but came to a different conclusion. Both cases involved an unpreserved instructional error that required review under the fundamental error doctrine. In both cases, the Court acknowledged the error. Both cases had instructions that were also correct, so both courts’ task involved reading the jury instructions as a whole.
So what explains the different results? In Dirig, the concept for which the jury received the erroneous instructions was central to the case. In Miles, the defendant never requested an instruction on voluntary manslaughter, so sudden heat was only a peripheral issue. In Miles, the State correctly explained that a knowing killing in sudden heat is voluntary manslaughter, while in Dirig the State’s closing mixed the correct and incorrect standards. Finally, the jury in Dirig heard a substantial amount of testimony on the erroneous “reasonable caregiver” standard; the same was not true about sudden heat in Miles.
Takeaways for Practitioners
Object, object, object! Both courts agreed that the instructions were wrong. Had there be an objection, there would have been no need to analyze the issue under the most difficult burden on appeal to meet: fundamental error.
Where as an appellate practitioner you do not have a preserved error, strengthen your argument on appeal by: (1) connecting the State’s witnesses’ testimony to the erroneous instruction; (2) argue that your case has unusual facts that makes it uniquely affected by the erroneous instructions; and (3) push back on any potential argument that the error helped your client.