Last week the Indiana Court of Appeals published its opinion in Miles v. State, No. 26A-CR-455 (Ind. Ct. App. Nov. 12, 2026). Chief Judge Tavitas wrote for the Court; Judge Felix concurred; Judge Bradford concurred in part and in result in part with a separate opinion.
Indiana trial courts keep giving voluntary manslaughter instructions that get the logic backwards, and Indiana appellate courts keep saying so. In Miles, the Court of Appeals agreed that the jury received an erroneous voluntary manslaughter instruction. However, because there was no objection, and because there was another jury instruction that correctly stated the law, the Court held there was no fundamental error.
The Facts
Charles Miles believed that Corey Fisher, his wife’s ex-boyfriend, had sent her sexually explicit images several months earlier. One evening in June 2024, Miles was riding in a friend’s Jeep when they stopped at an Evansville gas station and saw Fisher walk into the store. When Fisher came out, Miles tried to punch him, missed, and fell. Fisher ran toward his house.
The Jeep’s driver then drove off, passed Fisher, parked in a dark spot near Fisher’s home, and turned off the lights. Fisher picked up a piece of asphalt along the way. When Miles and the driver ran out of the darkness toward him, Fisher struck Miles above the eye with the asphalt. The men went to the ground, and Miles and the driver beat and kicked Fisher for about 30 seconds, stopping only when a car pulled up to the intersection. Fisher walked to a neighbor’s porch, collapsed, and died later from his injuries.
The Instructions
The State charged Miles with murder. At trial, Miles requested instructions on involuntary manslaughter, reckless homicide, and voluntary manslaughter. Two final jury instructions addressed voluntary manslaughter.
Final Instruction No. 5 told the jury that voluntary manslaughter was a lesser included of murder; that if the State proved murder, the jury need not consider the included offense; and that if the State failed to prove murder, the jury could consider voluntary manslaughter.
Final Instruction No. 6, which Miles requested, correctly defined voluntary manslaughter, explained that sudden heat is a mitigating factor that reduces what otherwise would be murder, placed the burden on the State to disprove sudden heat beyond a reasonable doubt, and walked the jury through the proper sequence: if the jury proved the four murder elements but failed to disprove sudden heat, the jury could find Miles guilty of voluntary manslaughter.
In closing arguments, the defense asked for the jury to find Miles guilty of reckless homicide or involuntary manslaughter. The State argued in rebuttal that there was no sudden heat. The jury convicted Miles of murder.
The Majority: Error, But Not Fundamental
The Court of Appeals readily agreed with Miles that Instruction No. 5 was wrong. Because sudden heat mitigates what would otherwise be murder, a jury considers voluntary manslaughter only after finding the elements of murder, not after finding the State failed to prove the elements of murder. Miles’ concern was that the erroneous instruction may have led the jury to to stop deliberating after it found a knowing killing, never considering whether Miles acted in sudden heat.
But Miles did not object to the erroneous instruction, so on appeal he was required to show fundamental error. This required Miles showing that the instructions as a whole were so misleading as to make a fair trial impossible. Reading the instructions together, the Court held that the correct instruction (Instruction no. 6) cured any confusion.
Two Footnotes Worth Reading
The “lesser-included” label. In a footnote, the majority observed that voluntary manslaughter is not a typical lesser-included offense. It requires something more than murder (sudden heat), not less. The Court left for another day whether voluntary manslaughter is still a “lesser-included” offense.
Sufficiency of sudden heat evidence. The parties disputed whether the evidence even warranted a voluntary manslaughter instruction. The majority declined to reach that question but reminder5 readers that any appreciable evidence of sudden heat justifies a voluntary manslaughter instruction.
Judge Bradford’s Separate Opinion
Judge Bradford agreed there was no fundamental error but would have gone further and held any error harmless. In his view, the voluntary manslaughter instructions should never have been given. because there was not enough evidence to justify giving the instructions.
As for the footnote about the “lesser-included” offense label, Judge Bradford argued that, in his view, treating voluntary manslaughter as a lesser-included offense is exactly what produced the erroneous jury instruction. He proposed referring to voluntary manslaughter as a “lesser non-included offense.”